8 min read

Take Control of your Practice: A Therapist's Guide to Depaneling and Thriving with Out-of-Network Billing

Feeling restricted by insurance panels? This comprehensive guide is here to empower you throughout your transition to a private-pay practice.
Written by
Rachel Hodes
Published on
May 15, 2024

A Therapist's Guide to Depaneling and Thriving with Out-of-Network Billing

Feeling restricted by insurance panels? The current healthcare landscape can leave therapists feeling trapped by the limitations of insurance. Navigating complex billing practices and battling limitations on treatment options can hinder the essence of your practice and draw focus away from your clients.

This comprehensive guide is here to empower you throughout your transition to a private-pay practice. We'll delve into the world of depaneling, the process of opting out of insurance networks, and transitioning to a system of out-of-network (OON) claim submission. This guide will equip you with the knowledge and tools to make informed decisions about your practice, prioritize client care, and potentially unlock greater financial freedom.

We'll begin by demystifying the world of National Provider Identifiers (NPIs) and how they impact your insurance relationships. You'll learn how to identify your current panel status and gain a step-by-step understanding of the depaneling process itself. Whether you're considering leaving all insurance networks or just a select few, this guide will equip you with the knowledge and strategies to navigate the transition smoothly.

We'll also address special considerations for therapists working with credentialing companies like Headway and Alma, and clarify the differences between active and passive depaneling. The guide doesn't stop there. We understand the anxieties that can arise during the "dead time" between depaneling and submitting OON claims. We'll equip you with strategies to manage this period and ensure a smooth transition.

Finally, we'll introduce you to Mentaya, a platform designed to streamline the OON claim submission process. From automated billing to expert support, Mentaya can be your partner in navigating this transition. This guide, coupled with Mentaya's resources, will empower you to reclaim control of your practice, prioritize client well-being, and thrive in a system that supports both therapists and their clients.

So, take a deep breath, therapist. You're not alone. This guide will equip you with the knowledge and tools to navigate depaneling with confidence and unlock a more fulfilling and financially sustainable practice.

Insurance Logistics: Understanding the Landscape

The world of insurance can feel like a labyrinth, and navigating it effectively is essential for a smooth transition to OON billing. This section will equip you with the knowledge of two key components: National Provider Identifiers (NPIs) and your current panel status.

Demystifying NPIs: Understanding 1 and 2

The National Provider Identifier, or NPI, is a unique 10-digit code assigned to healthcare providers and organizations. Understanding the two main NPI types is crucial:

  • NPI Type 1 (Individual Provider): This is your personal identifier, like a social security number for the healthcare world. It stays with you throughout your career, regardless of where you practice. It signifies that you, as an individual, are authorized to deliver services and bill for them.
  • NPI Type 2 (Organization): This identifier applies to groups, practices, or other entities like hospitals or clinics. An organization NPI is often linked to an Employer Identification Number (EIN), a tax identification number for businesses. Things can get a little complex when a single entity has multiple providers under its umbrella. We'll explore this further in the next section.

The Interplay Between Individual and Group NPIs

Now, let's delve into how these NPI types work together in the context of insurance panels:

  • Paneling with an NPI 1: When you directly contract with an insurance company as an individual provider, your NPI 1 is used to identify you on their network.
  • Paneling with an NPI 2: If you work for a group practice, the group's NPI 2 may be used for billing purposes, even though your individual services are being delivered. This can be the case with companies like Headway or Alma. We'll address these specific scenarios later in the guide.

Understanding this interplay is crucial because it will affect how you approach depaneling. When you transition to OON billing, you'll primarily rely on your individual NPI 1 for submitting claims.

Identifying Your Panel Status: Are You In or Out?

Knowing your current panel status with specific insurance companies is the first step towards depaneling. Here's how to find out:

  1. Investigate Insurance Company Websites: Most insurance companies allow you to search their provider directories online. Look for a section where you can verify your participation status by entering your NPI or name.
  2. Contact Insurance Representatives: Sometimes, information online may not be entirely accurate. Don't hesitate to contact the insurance company directly and speak with a representative from the provider network department. They can confirm your panel status and provide details about any termination clauses in your contract.

By following these steps, you'll gain a clear picture of your current insurance affiliations and be well-positioned to move forward with the depaneling process.

The Depaneling Process: Taking Control

Now that you've familiarized yourself with insurance logistics, let's navigate the specifics of depaneling. This section will equip you with strategies for a smooth transition, addressing considerations for group practices and unique situations.

Terminating Contracts: Understanding the Fine Print

Most insurance contracts will have a termination clause outlining the process for opting out of the network. Here's what you need to know:

  • Notice Periods: This clause typically specifies a required notice period before your depaneling becomes effective. This timeframe can vary depending on the insurance company, so carefully review your contract.
  • Instructions for Termination: The clause may outline specific steps you need to take to formally notify the insurance company of your intention to depanel. This might involve submitting a written notification or completing a specific form on their website.

Leaving a Group Practice? Additional Considerations:

Things can get trickier if you're currently affiliated with a group practice with its own NPI 2. Here's what to keep in mind:

  • Removal from Group Roster: You'll likely need to communicate your depaneling intentions to the group practice and ensure they remove you from their provider roster associated with the group NPI 2.
  • Contractual Obligations: Review your agreement with the group practice to understand any specific requirements related to depaneling. There might be additional notice periods or procedures to follow.

Strategies for a Smooth Transition: Full Stop or Partial Exit?

Once you understand the termination process, you can determine your depaneling strategy. Here are some options to consider:

  • Full Depaneling: This involves opting out of all your current insurance panels. This approach offers the most control over your rates and practice structure, but it also means your clients will need to pay out-of-pocket or utilize their out-of-network benefits.
  • Partial Depaneling: You can choose to leave the network of specific insurance companies while remaining in-network with others. This allows you to explore OON billing with a select group of clients while maintaining some insurance affiliations.

The best approach depends on your individual circumstances and practice goals. Consider factors like your client base, their insurance coverage, and your risk tolerance when making this decision.

Managing the Transition Period:

The period between initiating depaneling and being able to submit OON claims can feel like a "dead zone." Here's how to navigate this time:

  • In-Network Billing During Notice Period: During the required notice period, you can typically continue to bill services as in-network.
  • Confirmation of Depaneling: Once the notice period is complete, verify with the insurance company that your depaneling is finalized. This ensures a smooth transition to OON billing.

Special Considerations: Group Practices and Auto-Renewals

If you're affiliated with a company like Headway or Alma, their contracts might have additional complexities regarding depaneling. We'll explore these specific scenarios and any unique considerations in a later section.

Finally, be aware of "auto-renewal" clauses in some insurance contracts. These clauses can automatically renew your participation in the network unless you take specific steps to opt-out before the renewal date. Actively review your contracts to avoid unintended renewals.

By understanding the termination process, considering your depaneling strategy, and navigating the transition period effectively, you can ensure a smooth path towards OON billing.

Bridging the Gap: Transitioning to OON Billing with Mentaya

Depaneling might create a temporary gap between when you can no longer bill in-network and when you're officially set up for OON claims. This section will address this "dead time" and how Mentaya can help you navigate this phase seamlessly.

Making the Most of the Transition Period

The period between depaneling and submitting OON claims doesn't have to be unproductive. Here are some strategies to manage this time effectively:

  • Focus on Client Communication: Be transparent with your clients about your transition to OON billing. Explain the timeline and any potential changes to their out-of-pocket costs.
  • Review and Update Client Information: Ensure you have accurate insurance information for all your clients. This will streamline the OON claims submission process once you're ready.
  • Explore Mentaya's Platform: Familiarize yourself with Mentaya's platform in advance. This way, you'll be prepared to hit the ground running when it's time to submit OON claims.

Important Note on Billing During Transition:

During the notice period outlined in your termination clause, you can typically continue to bill services as in-network. However, any services rendered after your official depaneling date will need to be submitted as OON claims.

A Smooth Landing: Mentaya to the Rescue

Mentaya can be your partner in navigating the transition to OON claims. Here's how their platform can streamline the process:

  1. Simple Onboarding: Our platform is designed for ease of use. The onboarding process is straightforward, allowing you to quickly get set up for OON claims submission.
  2. Streamlined Claim Management: Say goodbye to manual paperwork! Mentaya automates claim submission, verification, and follow-up, saving you valuable time and reducing errors.
  3. Client Communication Tools: Mentaya provides tools to easily communicate with your clients about their OON claims and benefits. This ensures transparency and reduces confusion throughout the process.
  4. Dedicated Support: Mentaya's team is here to support you throughout your transition. They offer expert guidance and resources to ensure a smooth shift to OON billing.

By leveraging Mentaya's platform and support, you can bridge the gap between depaneling and OON claims submission with confidence, minimizing disruption to your practice and ensuring a positive experience for your clients.

This comprehensive guide has equipped you with the knowledge and tools to navigate the depaneling process with confidence. We've explored key concepts like National Provider Identifiers (NPIs), the intricacies of insurance panels, and the steps involved in successfully terminating contracts.

We've also addressed strategies for navigating the transition period and highlighted the benefits of transitioning to out-of-network (OON) billing. Mentaya's platform can be your key partner in this process, streamlining claim submission, communication, and overall practice management.

Remember, depaneling can be a strategic move towards greater control over your practice and potentially increased income. By following the steps outlined in this guide and leveraging the support available through Mentaya, you can make a smooth transition and build a thriving private practice.

So, take a deep breath, and embrace the opportunity to create a practice environment that aligns with your values and goals. Mentaya is here to support you every step of the way.

Additional Resources

This guide has equipped you with a strong foundation for depaneling and transitioning to OON billing. However, the world of insurance can be complex, so here are some additional resources to support you on your journey:

About Mentaya

Mentaya is a platform designed to empower therapists like you to thrive in their practice and support private pay clients. Our mission is to make affordable therapy accessible to all through automating claim submission, streamlining practice management, and ensuring a seamless transition for both therapists and their clients.

Here's how Mentaya can support you:

  • Effortless OON Claim Management: Say goodbye to paperwork! Our platform automates claim submission, verification, and follow-up, saving you countless hours and minimizing errors.
  • Enhanced Client Communication: Mentaya provides built-in tools to easily communicate with your clients about their OON claims and benefits. This transparency fosters trust and reduces confusion throughout the process.
  • Dedicated Therapist Support: Our team of insurance experts is here to guide you every step of the way. We offer personalized support, resources, and ongoing education to ensure your success with out-of-network billing.

By partnering with Mentaya, you gain more than just a claims processing tool. You gain a dedicated partner invested in your success and committed to helping you build a thriving practice.

Visit our website at Mentaya.com to learn more about how Mentaya can empower you to take control of your practice and achieve your financial goals.

We wish you the best of luck on your journey to a fulfilling and financially sustainable private practice!

Stay plugged in on all things "out of network" therapy
No spam. Just our best resources on insurance insights, time-saving tips, and helpful articles like this – delivered right to your inbox.
Read about our privacy policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Avatar photoAvatar photoAvatar photo

Ready to learn more?